Okay, OBVIOUSLY Black Swan is better written than Tron Legacy, Carl. All I was saying is that within the world of the super duper 3D blockbuster light cycle extravaganza, Tron did a good (but not great) job. For the type of movie that it is, it works. Black Swan is not a reasonable point of comparison, even in sarcastic film snob speak. You know what is a good point of comparison? The original Tron, which it is about on par with.
I would hesitate to call Tron Legacy “plotty”, at least under my usage of the word plot. I called it busy, which it is, since it’s a movie that is rather heavy on action sequences. “Plotty” seems to imply something that is overly plotted and intricate to the point where the story loses steam. If you asked me to name a movie that was plotty, I would probably say something like Inception. (Note: once again, Inception is a better film and plotty is not always a bad thing).
Tron, if anything, has too little going on plot wise for the characters to interact with. I mean, it’s pretty much just an extended chase scene, as some critics have noted. With the one small exception of the explanation about the ISOs, which are entirely extraneous to the film, I would not call Tron overplotted. How can you call it plotty when it’s missing a MAJOR plot explanation in the Rinzler/Tron transformation that comes about at a rather pivotal moment in the film?
This might just be a semantics issue.
For those of you who aren’t Carl who are reading this, Black Swan is excellent. If you haven’t seen it yet, do so. It’s probably jumped to my favorite Aronofsky movie and I’m sure it’ll be the contender for a huge amount of awards. And yeah, it’s better than Tron Legacy, though it does have shittier effects
I’m not actually sure Carl and I disagree on this movie. I think this is just a question of expectations and putting our reactions in context. Whoa, Tron Legacy was written by two of the LOST writers (Adam Horowitz and Edward Kitsis). It’s entirely weird to have me on the less negative side of this equation.
As one last bit of Tron Legacy related business, it turns out I’ve met the dude who plays CLU (pre Jeff Bridges digital fanciness). His name is John Reardon, and he’s always at this Christmas party we go to every year. I feel like I know the dude in the Darth Vader suit or something… it’s cool, but it’s insignificantly cool. But it’s cool!
Also, I’m writing this post from Halifax. Yaaaay.
- Kev